Installation situation of a Minol Minolcal heat meter

Even when radiator valves are closed, consumption readings can still appear, especially in single-pipe heating systems with heat meters, because physical processes like heat conduction or circulation continue to register the meter. This effect is therefore a natural occurrence and does not represent a fault in the measuring system. The German Heating Costs Ordinance (Heizkostenverordnung) takes this into account by dividing the total costs into fixed costs and consumption costs.

Why does the heat meter show consumption even though the radiator is switched off?

Many tenants and landlords are puzzled when they see consumption readings on radiators with heat meters that are switched off . The radiators are cold, the valves are closed – and yet the meter still registers consumption. Is this a measurement error? No. This behavior is normal, understandable, and technically explainable.

This is how measurement works with single-pipe heating systems.

Many buildings use horizontal single-pipe heating systems. In this system, heating water is continuously circulated through a ring main to which all radiators in the apartment are connected.

The heat meter measures:

  • Heating water flow rate (via volume meter)
  • Flow temperature (at the apartment entrance)
  • Return temperature (at the apartment outlet)
Operating principle of a heat meter.
Pipe routing in horizontal single-pipe heating systems. Heating water circulation (red) also occurs when thermostatic valves are switched off and is measured by heat meters.
Pipe routing in horizontal single-pipe heating systems. Heating water circulation (red) also occurs when thermostatic valves are switched off and is measured by heat meters.

Is that fair? Yes – through basic and usage costs.

The Heating Costs Ordinance takes this effect into account:
Between 30% and 50% Heating costs must be billed as basic costs based on living space – and 50% to 70% based on measured consumption.

Advantages of the division:

  • The unavoidable base heating costs are compensated via the living space allowance.
  • Only the additional, controllable consumption is included in the consumption costs.
  • The price per kWh is lower with mixed billing than with pure consumption billing.

More on allocation keys in heating cost statements

How can consumption be completely stopped?

Only by closing the shut-off valves at the apartment entrance (if present and permitted) can the circulation of the heating water be interrupted and the basic heating stopped.

But attention:

  • Without basic heating, the apartment remains cold.
  • In case of frost, there is a risk of pipe damage and water damage.
  • Therefore, a complete shutdown should only be recommended with caution.

Conclusion: Consumption readings despite cold radiators are not a mistake

Consumption readings on radiators with heat meters that are switched off are due to technical reasons and do not indicate a defective meter. The small amount of heat emitted through the distribution pipes is unavoidable and is recorded correctly. The Heating Costs Ordinance ensures that this basic heating is distributed fairly – no resident pays too much.

Author

Title page of the handbook on heat cost accounting

Quelle: Handbuch der Wärmekostenabrechnung | Frank Peters Minol Messtechnik W. Lehmann GmbH & Co. KG, 2019

A man looks at his tablet and reads the Minol newsletter.
Minol Newsletter

Always up to date

* required fields

This field is for validation and should not be changed.